The Nizkor Project: Remembering the Holocaust (Shoah)

Shofar FTP Archive File: people/s/scott.william/lies/scott-10q


Newsgroups: alt.revisionism,alt.politics.nationalism.white,alt.politics.white-power
Subject: Eight Questions for William "Roger Hughes/Ian McKinney"  Scott 
X-Remember: http://www.nizkor.org
X-Search: http://www.nizkor.org/search.html 
X-Scott: http://ftp.nizkor.org/ftp.cgi?people/s/scott.william/

Archive/File: people/s/scott.william/lies/scott-10q
Last-Modified: 1997/01/11

Question One - November, 1996 
-----------------------------

   In response to my comment that "My parents, you see, taught me to 
   be discriminating in my choice of women," you responded with:

      "Ya, traitors, communists, and Jews only." (Scott, National
      Alliance Shrew-Step)

   Please identify the women in my life that, were, in your words,
   "traitors, communists and Jews only." List them by name and
   relationship... or, of course, admit, in front of the entire
   Internet, that you are a liar.

   I'll wait.

Question Two - November 1996
----------------------------

   In November, during the abortive National Alliance attack upon
   a militia newsgroup, you parotted the Pierce line concerning
   Jewish "control" of the media:

      "I couldn't care less about the Jews practising their religion. 
      What I object to is their legacy of subversion, manipulation and 
      censorship. And most importantly their control of the media." 
      (Scott, Question to Militia-Types)

   As you have made this claim, I assume that you are now prepared to 
   substatiate it by providing the answers to the questions which follow.
   The answers to most of these questions are, by the way, readily 
   available from the appropriate American and Canadian government 
   agencies, so it is safe to assert that you will encounter no 
   difficulty providing the data. Market data is published regularly by 
   the media themselves.

   How many newspaper publishers are there in North America?
   How many are privately held?
   How many of those are held by Jewish investors?
   How many are traded on the exchange?
   How many are held by controlling Jewish investors?
   How large is their market share?

   How many magazine publishers are there in North America?
   How many are privately held?
   How many of those are held by Jewish investors?
   How many are traded on the exchange?
   How many are held by controlling Jewish investors?
   How large is their market share?

   How many cable broadcasters are there in North America?
   How many are privately held?
   How many of those are held by Jewish investors?
   How many are traded on the exchange?
   How many are held by controlling Jewish investors?
   How large is their market share?

   How many radio broadcasters are there in North America?
   How many are privately held?
   How many of those are held by Jewish investors?
   How many are traded on the exchange?
   How many are held by controlling Jewish investors?
   How large is their market share?

   How many television broadcasters are there in North America?
   How many are privately held?
   How many of those are held by Jewish investors?
   How many are traded on the exchange?
   How many are held by controlling Jewish investors?
   How large is their market share?

Question Three - November 1996
------------------------------

   A busy little bigot in November, you also claimed that author
   David Irving was being suppressed by "the Jews:"

      "Look around, you'll find the Jews are constantly trying to 
      suppress someone else's Free Speech. David Irving can't even 
      get his books published due to Jewish pressure." (Scott, 
      Question to Militia-Types) 

   Please name the book that David Irving has been unable to
   publish. Please demonstrate how "the Jews" suppressed any
   book written by Mr. Irving.

Question Four - November 1996
-----------------------------

   Perhaps it was the fact that the National Alliance was promoting
   Mr. Irving in November that led you to claim:

      "Of course, Irving was widely praised and published all over 
      before he determined that some of the stories concerning the 
      'holocaust' were just that - stories. Now, he's being banned." 
      (Scott, Question to Militia-Types)

   I direct you to multiple reviews of Mr. Irving's work, which
   may be examined at URL 
   http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/i/irving-david/reviews, and
   ask you to contrast these reviews with your contention that
   Mr. Irving was "praised ... all over," above. I would then ask
   that you consider the material to be found nearby, under the
   heading "What have professional historians had to say about
   Irving's work?" and contrast the words of the historians with
   your contention that he was "praised ... all over."

   The second part of the question, Mr. Scott, will address the 
   issue of Mr. Irving's bannings. Please explain where he has
   been banned, and why. If you need assistance, I submit URLs
   
   http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/i/irving-david/australia/fc-index.html
   http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/i/irving-david/australia/wag-107-index.html
   http://www.nizkor.org/hweb/people/i/irving-david/canada/iat-index.html
   
Question Five - November 1996
-----------------------------

   You have claimed that you "... never use alterernate IDs," 
   (Ibid., A Suggestion) Mr. Scott. As even a cursory examination
   of your userid shows, this is specious nonsense.

   On October 19, 1996, for instance, SMTP confirmed that the
   userid "mckinney@gate.usaor.net" was, in fact, registered to
   one William Scott.

   On January 9, 1997, SMTP confirmed that the userid
   "ipm@gate.usaor.net" was, in fact, registered to one 
   William Scott.

   The question is very simple, Mr. Scott. Why did you lie about
   your userids? Were you "Mr. McKinney," as you claimed at the
   time, or were you, in fact, William Scott, as your ISP stated?

   And, in January, Mr. Scott, were you "Mr. Hughes," as you 
   claimed at the time, or were you, in fact, William Scott,
   as your ISP stated?

Question Six - November 1996
----------------------------

   Perhaps feeling the need to get someone - anyone - to pay more
   attention to your specious comments, you decided to shout:

      "NIZKOR IS VERY HOSTILE TO MILITIAS AND PATRIOTS. WHY WOULD AN 
      ANTI-AMERICAN OUTFIT LIKE NIZKOR BE PRESENT ON MAM AT THE 
      INVITATION OF `ARLIN ADAMS?' WHY WOULD `WIZARD'S' EMAIL ADDRESS 
      BE LINKED TO THIS PATRIOT-HATING ORGANIZATION?

      "We can only suspect that both `Wizard' and `Arlin Adams' are enemy 
      agents who operate on MAM to obtain information against real Patriots. 
      Information that would undoubtedly be directed to the Jewish 
      Anti-Defamation League and Morris Dees. NIZKOR WORKS CLOSELY WITH 
      THESE ANTI-AMERICAN ORGANIZATIONS.

      "NO REAL PATRIOT WOULD HAVE ANYTHING WHATSOEVER TO DO WITH 
      NIZKOR." (Scott, Wizard is Covert)

   Question Six is a multipart enterprise:

   A. Define the terms "militia" and "patriot."
   B. Demonstrate that the Nizkor Project is "hostile" to either
   C. Demonstrate that the Nizkor Project is "Anti-American."
   D. Demonstrate that either of the users you identify are or
      were "linked" to the Nizkor Project.
   E. Demonstrate that the Nizkor Project is a "patriot-hating"
      organization.
   F. Demonstrate that the Nizkor Project "works closely" with
      either the ADL or Mr. Dees.

   (Take your time, Mr. Scott.)

Question Seven - January 1997
-----------------------------

In January 1997, you made the following statement:

      "The ADL has been pushing various `model statutes' aimed at 
      censoring people on the net for the past couple of years. Don't 
      tell me you haven't heard about it?" (Scott, Nizkor: Who)

I responded to this statement with a request for documentation:

   "That's very interesting... I haven't run across such a model
   statute... why don't you provide it for us, Mr. Scott?

   "While you're at it, do tell us which ADL publication it appeared
   in, so we can look it up."

I am still waiting for your documentation, Mr. Scott.

Question  Eight - January 1997
------------------------------

In the same article, you also made the following claim:

      "Well, since the ADL defines anyone who contradicts the Jewish 
      version of WW2 as a 'Nazi', your statement obviously includes 
      everybody except the Jews and their dupes." (Scott, Nizkor: Who)

This was my response:

   "Now, I don't doubt for a moment the veracity of your claims, of
   course, but I would really not want to blindly accept them, even
   when they originate with a man known far and wide as a man of
   honour and integrity (who may change his name every month, but
   hey, who's counting?) as you surely must be.

   "So, in the interest of maintaining this stirling reputation, I am
   sure you will find it in your own interest to provide the answers
   to a few simple questions... I ask them only to clarify your clear
   and concise knowledge of the ADL and its reports, you understand.

   "First, please explain what the ADL considers as "the Jewish
   version of WW2." Demonstrate the accuracy of your assertion by
   showing your unlettered audience which ADL publications define
   this `Jewish version,' so we can all benefit from your wisdom and
   vast knowledge of these matters.

   "Second, of course, is a simple request to name the publication
   wherein the ADL stated that anyone who did not agree with this
   `Jewish version of WW2' was a Nazi. As you know, many of us are
   simply too stupid to think for ourselves, being white and all, so
   you'll have to provide page numbers and everything.

   I'll wait."

I am still waiting, Mr. Scott.

                           Work Cited

   Harris, Robert. Selling Hitler. New York: Pantheon Books, 1986.

   Scott, William, (Posting as "mckinney@usaor.net (Ian McKinney)").
      UseNet: misc.activism.militia. Subject: "Wizard is Covert Nizkor 
      Agent - Beware," Nov. 3, 1996.  Message-ID: 846992012$8466@atype.com

   -------------- (Posting as "mckinney@usaor.net (Ian McKinney)").
      UseNet: misc.activism.militia. Subject: "A Suggestion," 
      Nov. 4, 1996.  Message-ID: 847124285$18204@atype.com

   -------------- (Posting as "mckinney@usaor.net (Ian McKinney)").
      UseNet: misc.activism.militia. Subject: "Re: That Ol' National 
      Alliance Shrew-Step," Nov. 4, 1996.  Message-ID: 
      847137859$19325@atype.com

   -------------- (Posing as "mckinney@usaor.net (Ian McKinney)")
      UseNet: misc.activism.militia. Subject: "Re: Question to 
      Militia-Types: WHO are the TRUE patriots?," Nov. 4, 1996.
      Message-ID: 847126985$18452@atype.com

   -------------- (Posting as "ipm@usaor.net (Roger Hughes)").
      UseNet: alt.revisionism,alt.politics.white-power,
      alt.politics.nationalism.white. Subject: "Re: Nizkor: Who the 
      Hell are these guys?," Jan. 11, 1997. 
      Message-ID: 5b6teh$cp1@news.usaor.net



Home ·  Site Map ·  What's New? ·  Search Nizkor

© The Nizkor Project, 1991-2012

This site is intended for educational purposes to teach about the Holocaust and to combat hatred. Any statements or excerpts found on this site are for educational purposes only.

As part of these educational purposes, Nizkor may include on this website materials, such as excerpts from the writings of racists and antisemites. Far from approving these writings, Nizkor condemns them and provides them so that its readers can learn the nature and extent of hate and antisemitic discourse. Nizkor urges the readers of these pages to condemn racist and hate speech in all of its forms and manifestations.