The Nizkor Project: Remembering the Holocaust (Shoah)

Shofar FTP Archive File: people/l/littman.sol/press/plowing-the-net.980716

Anti-hate groups police the Internet

By HOLLIE SHAW -- The Canadian Press

TORONTO (CP) -- Every day, spies are prowling the Internet. 
Their mission: to track down hate-spewing Canadian Web sites. Their
methods are furtive, anonymity crucial. 
"We are systematically plowing the Net," says Sol Littman, Canadian
representative for the Simon Wiesenthal Centre. 
"If it involves a Canadian (Internet service) provider, we jump on it right
Last week, one of his "spies" uncovered a treasure trove of hate-mongering
aterial on a Web site in Sudbury, Ont. The Northern Information Exchange
offered a frightening glimpse of the pernicious mixture
of bigotry and violence. 
The detailed site contained a handbook for terrorists, a recipe for the
biological weapon anthrax, militia information, links to other hate sites, a
hand-grenade reference guide, and a blueprint for a "high energy, high
voltage device capable of producing potentially severe electrical shocks and
burns to a living organism." 
The site was shut down promptly after Littman contacted the
Sudbury-based service provider, Vianet. 
There would be at least 100 Canadian Web sites operating without the
centre's intervention, says the spy who uncovered the one in Sudbury. Now
there are about six, she says. 
Canadian law states you can't promote hate against identifiable groups. But
hate-busting on the Net, often touted as the last aegis of free speech, is
tricky. Offending sites can pop up and disappear lightning fast, and shutting
them down for good is never guaranteed. 
"Canada's hate laws are very badly drafted with respect to the Internet,"
says Littman. "It's very difficult to prosecute cases under them." 
Littman works with the Canadian Association of Internet Providers to root
out offensive material. 
"Most of the providers are very co-operative with us when we approach
them. We try a combination of gentle persuasion and a call for legal action to
get these people out of business." 
Lorien Gable, vice-president of operations at Toronto-based Interlog says
it's not the provider's job to police client's Web sites. 
"We have 50,000 customers and we don't monitor them," he says. 
"If a special interest group contacts us to complain about a site, 90 per cent
of the time it's not our issue and we'll tell them to go to the police or
government authorities," Gable says. 
"If it's illegal and an authority contacts us, we'll take it down." 
But there are exceptions, Gable says, such as if a Web site generated bad
publicity that started having an adverse effect on Interlog's business. 
"Then we reserve the right to (take that site down)." 
Still, any racist Canadian can take cover behind U.S. free-speech rights and
find a home on a variety of American sites. But Littman is optimistic an
airtight version of Canada's laws will one day be a global standard. 
"The Internet has certainly given the hate movement a second life. You can
sit in the anonymity of your basement with a cheap computer and reach
millions of people simultaneously." 

Home ·  Site Map ·  What's New? ·  Search Nizkor

© The Nizkor Project, 1991-2012

This site is intended for educational purposes to teach about the Holocaust and to combat hatred. Any statements or excerpts found on this site are for educational purposes only.

As part of these educational purposes, Nizkor may include on this website materials, such as excerpts from the writings of racists and antisemites. Far from approving these writings, Nizkor condemns them and provides them so that its readers can learn the nature and extent of hate and antisemitic discourse. Nizkor urges the readers of these pages to condemn racist and hate speech in all of its forms and manifestations.